Finally finished The Gathering Storm

Jason
Thursday
9:16 pm

The Gathering Storm coverRemember way back in October when all your heard me speak about was the impending release Robert Jordan and Brandon Sanderson’s The Gathering Storm, book 12 of the Wheel of Time series?

Remember how I got to be a really cool Storm Leader at a signing shortly after its release? Even Tor Books was nice enough to get me a copy a week early so I could read it and let you know how it was?

Well two nights ago I finally finished it, a cool four and a half months after the fact. I know, I know. Fail.

Its that whole slow reading thing, along with a break I took to read the new George R.R. Martin novella. Then there is the weekly comics as well. And mix in the laziness factor, and well now you know why we are creeping up on five months.

But I will fulfill my promise to let you know what I thought of the book.

First and foremost, even though it is obvious that Robert Jordan did not write most of the book, it is a great return to the world of The Wheel of Time. Sanderson did the series justice in The Gathering Storm, laying the ground work for a great run through the final two books of the series.

Jordan was a master at environment. A two page exposition on the way a field of grass looked and smell would have never surprised me. I love it. But Sanderson’s writing style is different from what WoT fans were used to reading. Not that the writing style is bad, it is just different. And sometimes that difference was evident as I made my way through the book.

The book itself has its ups and downs as well. Whether that was in the exposition, the plot or the writing, some things made me cheer and some others made me grumble under my breath. So what were my ups and downs?

Ups

  • It had been four years since I was last able to see what was going on in the Wheel of Time. Loved to be able to finally know what was going on with the characters I had invested so much time with. Well worth the wait if I must say so.
  • One of the biggest beefs readers had with the later books in the Wheel of Time series was all the loose threads going on in the world and no idea when, or if, they were going to start wrapping up. Well you know what? They started wrapping up. Egwene al’Vere and the White Tower was resolved, which was a major bonus feather in Sanderson’s cap in the way he wrote that particular story. The whole Siuan Sanche and Gareth Byrne lusting came to a resolution as well. And those pesky rumors about Verin Mathwin finally had some light shed on them. Things are winding down indeed.
  • Sanderson writes in a different style yes. However it is not intrusive to the overall book. Matter of fact, the action of the book draws you in so much so that you forget who is writing and you are just in the Wheel of Time.
  • We can be pretty certain that I don’t have to wait another four years for the next book. Sanderson has proven to be a workhorse of a writer in his young career and for that I am thankful. And if it all goes truly as he says, we should have the last book within two years.

Downs

  • Like I said before, I miss the nature of Jordan’s writing. Man was a genius.
  • I wanted more Perrin Aybara and Mat Cauthon, two of the original big three characters.
  • Mat was made somewhat of a little whiny bitch. He has the brain of generals past, but is reduced to moaning about this and that.
  • Same goes for Rand al’Thor. All dark and moody. Who ordered emo boy to show up?
  • While Sanderson nailed the White Tower storyline, the Aiel are an afterthought in this book. Very weird considering how much of a role they have played up to this point. Same to a certain extent with the Seanchan. I am wondering if maybe the high structure of each society was difficult to grasp in such a short time.

But in the end the ups far outweigh the downs. And for that I give two thumbs up to The Gathering Storm, Sanderson, and to Jordan’s legacy intact and going strong.

Reader Comments

Imagine, the sheer superhuman – nay, godlike – determination and fortitude required to make it even beyond book one of that series! Well done. I bow to you. :)

#1 
Written By Seth Armstrong on March 19th, 2010 @ 9:43 am

I don’t personally think the man was a genius, but I did miss his writing style, despite the fact that his character descriptions got tiresomely repetitive, and he was incredibly loquacious. I wasn’t all that enamored of Sanderson’s writing style, or the voice he gave many of the characters. But I forgive Sanderson all because stuff actually happened.

I’m still waiting for Lan’s point of view, though. Seriously. The novella does not count.

#2 
Written By Amber on March 19th, 2010 @ 9:56 am

As for Sanderson being a workhorse, we’ll see. He had to be before this, so that doesn’t exactly count.

#3 
Written By Amber on March 19th, 2010 @ 10:01 am

He was many things, but a genius definitely wasn’t one of them. To quote Alfred E. Neuman: Yecch!

#4 
Written By Seth Armstrong on March 19th, 2010 @ 10:04 am

Good review, but I have to disagree with you on these two points:
# Mat was made somewhat of a little whiny bitch. He has the brain of generals past, but is reduced to moaning about this and that.
# Same goes for Rand al’Thor. All dark and moody. Who ordered emo boy to show up?

If anything, that’s how Jordan has been writing the characters for more than half the series. Mat was always snitty and Rand was always brooding. At least this time they weren’t so flat and had more spark to their personalities. Mat actually had me laughing out loud in at least two places and it was fantastic to see the old Rand shine through.

#5 
Written By Anna on March 19th, 2010 @ 12:44 pm

I agree with Anna: Mat and Rand really weren’t out of character. And their typical character was always so one-dimensional that any change was welcome.

#6 
Written By Amber on March 19th, 2010 @ 1:01 pm

Robert Jordan was a hack. Didn’t anyone else notice what a ripoff The Eye of the World was? The Wheel of Time is the fantasy novel equivalent of Walker Texas Ranger.

#7 
Written By Jim King on March 20th, 2010 @ 8:29 am

I will respectfully disagree with you my friend Jim King. There are certain themes that will reverberate throughout all epic fantasy. Good vs evil. A master evil. A chosen one to save the world. It may have magic. It may not. And most will borrow from the history of the earth for some basis. Its all about how they get to end not the themes. And quite frankly Walker Texas Ranger can kick anyone ass so I am okay with that.

#8 
Written By Jason on March 20th, 2010 @ 10:09 am

I couldn’t make it past The Eye of the World, which seems more like a ripoff of a ripoff – i.e. a ripoff of the Shannara books, which were a ripoff of LOTR. So I disrespectfully disagree. It’s not really a question of common themes.

I do agree however that Walker kicks ass.

#9 
Written By Seth Armstrong on March 20th, 2010 @ 10:43 am

I still don’t know when I’ll be able to get my hands on the book. :\

The library in town seems to spend more money getting new romance novels every week to get anything else so no luck there… I’ll probably have to wait until I head to University in September, which saddens me.

#10 
Written By Nick Burns on March 21st, 2010 @ 1:31 am

You have a phone book, don’t you? Read that.

#11 
Written By Seth Armstrong on March 21st, 2010 @ 11:36 am

I actually enjoyed the books—more so 1 through 7 and the most recent, but all the same…. But they also contributed to me largely turning away from epic fantasy in recent years. It’s not just the rehashed storyline, which you find in all epic fantasy. It’s also the way they just seem to meander, or rather they alternate between wandering and rehashing what happened in the last 30 books. This is a calling card of epic fantasy, and Jordan adds to it characters who are largely without growth and dimension. He’s good at world building, but if I have to read one more time about Nynaeve yanking her braid, or about how Perrin knows more about women than Rand and vice versa, I’m going to scream.

#12 
Written By Amber on March 21st, 2010 @ 4:07 pm

Add a comment — we talk back!

Want your own avatar? Set one up through Gravatar, and it will appear on any Wordpress-powered blog. They show up based on the address you enter below.

required, use real name
required, will not be published
optional, your blog address